All the right moves but lost opportunities abound
COMMENTARY
NOV 5 - Tried and tested is probably the best description for the stimulus package announced by Prime Minister in waiting Datuk Seri Najib Razak yesterday. The package is unexciting overall but an extra RM7 billion is nothing to sneer at in times like these.
Similar measures have helped soften past hard landings for the economy -- boost the infrastructure and construction sectors, increase disposable income, keep the property sector afloat.
These helped Malaysia muddle through the aftermath of the Asian financial crisis ten years ago, and will probably work to some degree now.
But if the stimulus package is food for the body, the question that follows is what will Najib offer as food for the collective Malaysian soul?
When the Budget was unveiled in September the world was a much different place. People were bracing for more expensive fuel and dearer food, wondering how they were going to make ends meet in the face of rampant inflation.
Seven weeks later, the spiralling global financial crisis has cast different shadows on the immediate future. Falling house prices and toxic financial instruments have wreaked havoc in the US and UK, and threatened the stability of banks and insurance companies and roiled currencies around the world.
The price of oil has plunged, which has helped moderate inflation. But prices of commodities that Malaysia exports such as palm oil and rubber have nose-dived too.
Malaysia has been spared the worst so far, but confidence here is nonetheless low. The stimulus package offers the prospect of some immediate relief, but does little to alleviate a sense of "coulda, woulda, shoulda".
Now is probably not a good time to address some long-standing, deep-seated issues, but if we had done it when times were better, we might have built up some fat reserves against the lean times facing us tomorrow.
If only we had set a 10-year deadline in 2001 to reduce fuel subsidies to zero, we would probably have more than RM7 billion today to spend our way out of the approaching economic difficulties.
If only we had faced head on the protection for the national car Proton five years ago, we'd have cheaper cars now and more disposable income.
Years of high automotive tariffs on non-national cars has extracted a high cost in consumer welfare foregone and taken a toll on the economy.
Between 2001 and 2007, car buyers paid more than RM30 billion in duties and tariffs on the vehicles they bought. They forked out between RM9,000 and RM16,000 on average in taxes on each car purchased. And those who took car loans paid interest on those taxes.
Additional disposable income injected directly into the economy has a higher multiplier effect, so that money would probably have had a far bigger impact, in helping create jobs, say, than as development expenditure spent by the government. It would have more than made up for higher pump prices.
And it's probably too little, too late for Proton to say now it is ready to seek a foreign partner, when the world's car makers are slashing sales forecasts and seeking capital and financing.
If only the burden of the New Economic Policy on the economy could be addressed, and the ability of the country to compete on the global stage and attract foreign investment. But as recent events have shown, a thorough discussion on that issue is probably some way off.
If only we had made the most of opportunities as they came along, the country could perhaps have entered 2009 without a budget deficit which hampers attempts to spend our way out of a slowdown or recession.
Yesterday's stimulus package means the deficit will grow by a third, to 4.8 percent of gross domestic product, from the 3.1 percent announced in the Budget in September. And if a recession does strike, expect the deficit to swell further.
If only there was something that Najib could offer -- by way of commitment, of promises of a better future -- so Malaysians can see their way clear, not just for one year or the next, but for a long time to come!
* Report abuse
ReplyDelete* +2
* Report abuse
* Report abuse
A devil vs lameduck?
written by Candidmen, November 05, 2008
When macro economy is falling apart, the micro economy domestically must be consolidated and be taken care of to at least geared towards sustaining the anticipated inflation, in the looming despite the vaunted 'silver lining' that we ever have!
Implementation of mega projects, though they are catalysts to keep domestic growth and create more job opportunities, all should be vigilantly aimed at evicting the filthy practices of corruption so as to ensure every penny which is spent from national resources will help to benefit the public in terms of maximum gains! Liked it was before, only those in the executive level would prone to reap the cream and butter! Good deed had been turned into evil causes!
By and large, the general public still feel that this is not the time Najib should consider to spend in such exorbitant budgets in the military procurement, until and unless the economy tsunami is being dealt with and overcome! The increased deficit from 3.1 to 4.8% of GDP has demanded the rakyat years of slog to break even, compounded by the repayment of capital interests to the redundant procurements, will only drag the foot of national economic advancement and increase burdens of the rakyat for generations to go! Najib should deliberate a long term plan to benefit the rakyat instead of falling back to his self-seeking agenda which is main cause of people's lack of confidence in him! General perception still conceives he is agent and remnant of Mahatihrism which is more than unwelcome and unwanted!